21 Comments
This is not a post on having your kids write lists using bullet points. Not anymore. It’s a post about buying toys, and how hard it is to find open-ended, non-plastic toys, especially if you go to a big chain store like Toys R Us. (And, I’ll also tell you my only guideline for buying toys – hint: open-ended.)
Original Post – A Writing Activity:
This morning, I made my daily list of tasks in which I used bullet points. Little JJ wanted climbed up on my lap and began to color in my bullets. She asked what I was writing so I explained how I like to think about my day using a list. Then, I suggested that she and AJ make their birthday wish lists, trying to use bullet points. Both birthdays are coming up. I figured it’d be a fun way to get them writing. Of course, writing a wish list is very motivating in itself.
This would have been such a good post. But, then I went shopping, using the newly written birthday lists . . .
Quick Confession:
Admittedly, it’s my own fault that the girls’ wish lists got so commercialized with popular toys like Zoobles, Lego sets and Moxie Girls. AJ’s been sick, really sick, for a week and I let her watch a lot of television. And with television, she (and little sister) watched commercials. With commercials, they learned what they really wanted for their birthdays. (Fie on you T.V. and the mom that let her kids watch you!)
Here are their lists. (Gag me.)
JJ’s Birthday List: (She’s 5 so try to sound it out as best you can.)
AJ’s Birthday List: (I think we need to work a bit on the spelling, don’t you?)
Good grief, I can’t believe her spelling! But, we’ll save that for another time.

Okay, so the Lego thing AJ wanted was on sale at Toys R Us. So, like an idiot, I thought I’d check it out; normally I don’t go there. It was my third time ever and my last.
First, let me just say that the Lego sale was such a scam. The shelves were almost entirely empty. I presume there wasn’t a big line at the doorthis morning for a buy one get one half off Lego Set? Perhaps I’m wrong. But, we found the $39.99 Harry Potter Hogwarts Set and did not get it. I mean, really –$39.99 for this?
Short, Quick Rant About Legos:
And also, what the heck is wrong with Legos only selling kits? Where’s the creativity in following directions? There isn’t any! I seriously couldn’t believe that all the Legos were in kits – it’s totally disappointing and in my opinion, just about worthless in developing a child’s imagination and thinking skills. (Back in my day . . .)
Onto My Toys R Us Rant:
Maybe you already knew this but I couldn’t find any non-plastic toys at Toys R Us. (Okay, there were a few plush toys – most made noise so I don’t count them.) Really?
I could summarize the store with this: All the toys were plastic and made overseas, probably in China. To which I say, no thank you. Adios. Yuck.
Dear Kids,
Sorry, darling girls for letting you watch television. I think it made you believe you needed those plastic toys that you never even knew about before this week. My mistake. Next time, we’ll stick with movies.
I’ve decided to skip some things on your wish lists. I know you might feel disappointed, but I have my reasons. I want toys that allow you to be creative and use your imaginations. Not toys where you push a button and it walks, talks and poops while you watch. Believe me, you’d be bored with those do-everything toys anyway. I hope you can trust me on this one . . .
Love,
Your (mean and independent thinking?) mommy
P.S. Ask Grandma. Maybe she’ll get them for you.
My Toy Buying Guideline:
Toys must allow children to use their imaginations, think or create. In other words, open-ended, many possibility toys.
That’s it. My one guideline.
So, no toys with batteries, millions of plastic parts, or only one option for playing it.
And where do you buy these toys? Online or in small, locally-owned toy stores. Here are a few favorites toy companies – which I’ll stick to from now on. I’m sure I’m forgetting many other brands so please forgive me if you don’t see a favorite on the list. Comment with it!
- Melissa and Doug
- Shure
- Zillio
- Safari, Ltd.
- Ravensburger
- Eeboo
- Educational Insights
- National Geographic
- Cranium
- Fashion Angels
- Wikki Stix
- CitiBlocs
- Zoob (shown in photo above)
- Think Fun Games (thanks to Melissius)
- MakeDo (thanks to @ianchia)
- Grasshopper Store
- Land of Nod
- Mudpuppy
- Plan Toys
- Klutz (thanks Erin @LetterSoup for all these!)
- plus lots more!
What are your favorite online stores or toy companies?
RECENT POSTS:
Flip a Word Word Families Books











Melissa Taylor is a mom and educator from Denver who is passionate about playful learning. Thanks for visiting the site!

















21 Comments
I agree totally. We have a cupboard full of board games and so many toys that it’s rather embarrassing to admit how many, but they are mostly toys that can be played with in a variety of ways. We have a huge supply of craft materials too, that the kids can easily access. My children are 6, 9 and 11.
We do have quite a bit of Lego, including some that belonged to my husband as a child. My older son was given a few sets that had instructions for around 10 different things that you could build.
I have had a few bad experiences with Toys R Us, most involving terrible customer service. I tend to keep my eye out for interesting board games at my local Australian Geographic store or I track down recommendations from friends online. We have quite a few Dr Wood board games that we particularly enjoy.
I’m a big fan of Think Fun’s games like Zingo or What’s Gnu? For Christmas, my boys both wanted marble track, which I was able to get at the teacher supply store. They love Lego, and once the kits have been built, they love to take them apart and make their own creations.
For their birthdays, I asked that no one send toys. Books, art or science supplies get them just as excited. I’ll let you know if that worked.
We share the same philosophy about toys in our home. Great post Melissa
yes I agree it is like that in any toy aisle unless you go to a actual toy store but even then they have tons of plastic and kits. which are ok if evened out with creative toys.
You know what my toddler son spent the majority of the weekend playing with? An rocket sticker that Grandma sent him. It’s just a plain sticker, nothing fancy. That sticker has flown all around the house and well, it doesn’t much stick to anything right now anymore. And, when it was lost (happened several times because it’s very hard to keep track of a small sticker I’ve learned) he happily played with a paper airplane a.k.a rocket that he decorated himself. So much for all our toys.
Arts and crafts materials are a favorite here. One of the best purchases I’ve made is a box of 64 pip-squeak Crayola washable markers. Those get used every single day.
Dress-up costumes are also popular. My son loves his super hero cape and my daughter likes to dig into her random assortment of odd costumes and old clothes.
Melissa, I completely agree with your toy buying guidelines! We again are like minded! The following is what I posted in my December Newsletter on this topic!
Toys that are best for brains….
* Provide an opportunity for direct interaction and manipulation
* Give a child a chance to develop something with their hands
* Offer a variety of ways of using the toy or object
* Spark imagination and creativity
* Allow the child to repeat a process
* Promotes physical activity
Examples are: Puzzles, building blocks, building sets,
crayons, balls, paints, play dough, dolls, trucks and
cars, shape sorters, sand toys, bean bags, nesting
cups, pretend play materials, an empty box, water toys, and books!
…. Opportunities to just play, create , explore, and manipulate
objects provides the best opportunities for real learning.
When these activities are driven by a child’s own interests
you will almost be able to see brain connections being
made!
Have I told you lately how I adore you? And, not just because you agree with me – although, that’s quite nice, too!
But, you are such an amazing advocate for children! Thank you, from all the children in the world and their parents!
Hugs!
P.S. and when do I get to buy you coffee in Colorado????
What a great post. Agree with it all except for the Go ask grandma part. I’m a grandma and HATE all this junk! When my kids were young we had a rule in our house (and our oldest is 40 so this was a long time ago): If you see it on TV or hear about it advertised anywhere, we don’t buy it. Simple as that.
We did have legos, lots of them which our grandkids still use. They came in kits even then but my kids had no real interest in copying and rarely did.
I have all kinds of blocks which the kids use in so many ways. Love Tegu, the maganetic blocks (eco-friendly too) and just bought a raft of thin wood ones that can be stacked up in so many different ways. Grandkids also love dressing up so a trip to Goodwill to stock up while returning old stuff is always a great birthday gift.
Happy to know I’m not the only one out there that is disappointed in what’s out there for kids
I’m not a parent but I do babysit a cute little 2yo and the first time I went out to buy a bday gift for her I was thoroughly confused and frustrated. I’m not going to buy a doll for a 2yo with age inappropriate makeup and clothes, nor am I going to buy toys that play for her. I was a Lego and Dolly Pops kid, my parents never sprung for video games or even a Teddy Ruxpin that was so much the fad at the time. Finally after, I kid you not, 30mins of scouring the story for an appropriate toy I found something. Similar to the Dolly Pops from the 80s, Pop on Pals. They’re plastic but they promote motor development and actually require a little imagination. Discovery Toys and Zany Brainy also used to sell great stuff, but I haven’t checked them out recently. The little girl I babysit also has tons of Melissa and Doug (previously mentioned), and loves playing with their puzzles and doll houses (her parents also don’t buy her electronic toys).
Thanks for a great post!
And the (free) cardboard boxes & junk from ends of jumble sales go down pretty well too
Thanks for bringing up the subject.
It’s puzzles, books, crayons and paper for my daycare. Big empty boxes, colored paper flower petals, leafs, and cheerios and glue. Puppets and dress up from ARC. We have a great time going to the garage sales, and planting in flower pots. We do not like the plastic toys to pollute the Earth.
We’re thinking alike again! I have a post scheduled for next week with some of the same points. I agree, open ended toys that spark imagination=YAY! Commercials=Boo! Besides the brands you mentioned, we like Plan Toys, Mudpuppy and Klutz products . I love Land of Nod and http://www.grasshopperstore.com for quality toy selections. We are huge fans of Lego because my boys love building the kit once and then tearing it apart to build their own creations. Oh, and now, thanks to TV, my boys are obsessed with professional sports teams and the accompanying “official” gear. (Not to mention the commercials that play during the games, but that’s a whole different can of worms.) Anyway… Great post, as always!
thanks, Erin – I just added these to the post and linked to you. Great! I forgot about Klutz – and didn’t know of the others. Yeah!! Come back next week and link to your post so we can all visit. (Well, I subscribe so I will anyway.)
What’s with us? Twins separated at birth?
[...] No Birthday Wishes at Toys R Us [...]
You’re preaching to the choir…I can’t stand Toys R Us, so I’m glad you gave me permission to quit looking at their sales fliers in hopes of finding a deal. So here’s my latest “find”…it may not seem educational, but along with great exercise, you can get some mental math into the mix. I bought Creatology Skip Balls for the boys last summer ($1 bin at Michael’s) and stashed them away…just found them hidden away in time for Valentine’s Day. They are back in the bins (brighter colors) at Michael’s. I loved them back in the day. There’s a plastic (oops…sorry, plastic, but really fun toy) loop to put around your ankle with a 2 ft (or so) cord with a bouncy twisted ball-like thing on the end. Did you have one growing up? I even got them to practice their spelling words saying a letter each time the ball goes around when them jump over it. So, after all the exercise, they both came in and practiced piano without complaints. All of that for just $2 total! Oh, by the way…this ‘ole girl can still do it!
Check out KEVA planks. They are wonderful! Open-ended and fun for a wide range of ages. Our family (extended) loves them! Read more…
http://www.empoweredbyplay.org/2009/07/keva-planks-creating-fun-for-everyone-2/
I totally agree re:Toys R Us. I realized it about 10 years ago as I ventured in to buy generic animal puppets for my three-year-old niece. They had nothing that wasn’t media-linked. Nothing. I had to go to a specialty toy store to buy good puppets.
When I was a child we had a house rule – if I toy is advertised on TV, we can’t get it. Pretty great rule, I’d say. Now as a parent, we don’t have TV (yet we are addicted to Netflix!).
Agreed re: LEGO kits – so much is media-linked and violent, too. Disheartening at times.
Great post…Keep on fighting the good fight!
PURE PLAY KIDS!
[...] No Birthday Wishes at Toys R Us [...]
[...] No Birthday Wishes at Toys R Us [...]
I so agree!
Another cool source is http://etsy.com for handmade stuffed toys, felt playsets, etc. Because these are handmade artisan items you do have to be careful about choking hazards, etc. but I sure wish Etsy had been around when my kids were younger!
I totally loved this post Melissa! You are so right. As I look around the house at tons of stuff that my kids really don’t play with, I’m a little ashamed. We do have a ton of Schleich animals and dinosaurs and knights, and they are fabulous! Love the open-ended play that springs forth…